‘Tis the season to take a break from the routine and celebrate the holidays. I’ll get back to my usual artist spotlight next time, but today I want to share some of my favorite Christmas songs recorded by (mostly) ‘90s country artists.
I’ve established a couple of rules for the playlist.
Rule No. 1
I’m only including artists that were actively recording or performing in the 1990s. That lets me sneak in Brad Paisley and Montgomery Gentry, who debuted in ’99, though they didn’t release Christmas songs until the ’00s.
Unfortunately, the rule eliminates recent country covers, including Carrie Underwood’s “Do You Hear What I Hear” and Brett Eldredge’s “I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day.” These are both worthy additions to other holiday playlists but don’t fit the bill for this one.
Rule No. 2
Since my focus is on country music, many legends of the season are missing. While I hope you’ll add my country favorites to your Christmas playlist, make sure to include the classics: Dean Martin, Nat King Cole, Bing Crosby, Rosemary Clooney, and Elvis. Lots of Elvis.
Rule No. 3
While my all-genre Christmas playlist on Amazon Music includes entire albums, for this list, I’ve limited myself to only one song per artist.
Not a rule, but a rant
Is Die Hard a Christmas movie? Use that mentality to consider songs like “Let It Snow” or “Winter Wonderland.” They don’t specifically mention Christmas, but we accept them as seasonal songs. It would be weird to hear them playing at the grocery store in July.
Dolly Parton’s “Hard Candy Christmas” and Merle Haggard’s “If We Make It Through December,” however, should be enjoyed year round. They aren’t Christmas songs, although Dolly’s certainly feels more Christmas-y.
But it doesn’t matter how much I like the artist — Martina McBride, Trisha Yearwood, Brad Paisley — I cannot abide “My Favorite Things” being passed off as a Christmas song. It is not. Play it in April or September, but do not play it for Christmas.
With that off my chest, we can dive into the list.
My Top 25 Country Christmas Songs
Alphabetized by artist’s first name
“Tennessee Christmas” — Alabama
From their 1982 album Christmas. Written by Gary Chapman and Amy Grant.
Before Amy Grant married Vince Gill and into the country music family, she and her first husband wrote “Tennessee Christmas,” a song that perfectly captures Christmas in the volunteer state. Including her recording on the list would violate Rule No. 2, so I chose the Bama boys’ version. Eight-year-old Crystal would give the nod to “Thistlehair the Christmas Bear,” but middle-age Crystal hopes for a “tender Tennessee Christmas.” (I will accept any arguments that “Christmas in Dixie,” written by band members Mark Herndon, Randy Owen, Jeff Cook, and Teddy Gentry, is the more suitable option for the group’s entry on this list.)
“Holly Jolly Christmas” — Alan Jackson
From his 1993 album Honky Tonk Christmas. Written by Johnny Marks.
Alan put his honky-tonk spin on the season with a package of new and old favorites that included some compelling duet partners in Alison Krauss, Keith Whitley, and even Alvin and the Chipmunks. His smooth baritone wraps “Holly Jolly Christmas” up like a present under the tree.
“364 Days to Go” — Brad Paisley
From his 2006 album Brad Paisley Christmas. Written by Brad Paisley and Kevin Marcy.
If you like electric guitar solos and Christmas music, Brad Paisley is your guy. (He recently released his second Christmas album, Snow Globe Town, with even more solos.) But in “364 Days to Go,” Brad’s knack for capturing life’s small details shines as he paints the soft glow of Christmas night through the eyes of a six‑year‑old — a mix of wonder and restless anticipation.
“Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” — Brenda Lee
Recorded in 1958 with a B-side of “Papa Noel.” Written by Johnny Marks.
I may have cheated just a bit, but Brenda Lee was performing in the ‘90s. In fact, the 80-year-old rockabilly pioneer is still performing — and this hit is by far her biggest. She was only 13 years old when she recorded what would become a beloved Christmas favorite. I don’t remember the first time I heard it, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was in the 1990 movie, “Home Alone,” which gave Brenda Lee a late career boost. Check out this video of Ms. Brenda describing the song she calls a “gift.”
“Milk and Cookies (‘Til Santa’s Gone)” — Clint Black
From his 1995 album Looking for Christmas. Written by Clint Black, Hayden Nicholas, and Shake Russell.
Clint and his cowriters put themselves inside the mind of the song’s 5-year-old narrator to channel those night-before-Christmas jitters: Close my eyes and concentrate/ I gotta sleep now it’s getting late/ All night long I lie awake/ ‘Til Santa’s gone I just can’t wait. Paired with a bright melody and Clint’s harmonica licks, this song is a ‘90s country classic.
“Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” — Crystal Gayle
From her 1986 album A Crystal Christmas. Written by Hugh Martin and Ralph Blane.
I have a vivid memory of watching this music video on CMT at my grandparents’ house on a Christmas Eve night when I was little. With her long, black hair flowing, Crystal descends a staircase wearing a chic white sweater and dark slacks. She quickens the tempo to give the song a different feel than what you’ll hear from Judy Garland or Crystal’s fellow country singer Vince Gill. Hers is more hopeful than melancholy, and I’m for it.
“With Bells On” — Dolly Parton & Kenny Rogers
From their 1984 album Once Upon a Christmas. Written by Dolly Parton.
You can’t listen to this one without tapping your foot and smiling along, but I should address why “Hard Candy Christmas,” written by Carol Hall, didn’t make the list. Dolly has said the song isn’t a Christmas song, but she included it on this album and has performed it for various Christmas specials. Unlike “My Favorite Things,” I like hearing it this time of year. It’s on my all-genre Christmas playlist in various forms — from Reba’s stripped-down acoustic cover to Trisha Yearwood backed by an orchestra. Just this week, I discovered Zach Top’s version on YouTube. Still, Dolly’s will always be the best.
“Santa Claus is Back in Town” — Dwight Yoakam
From his 1997 album Come on Christmas. Written by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller.
Since I couldn’t include Elvis on this list (see Rule No. 2), I chose an artist who has the same self-assured swagger as the King. His rendition of one of Elvis’s Christmas classics is as feisty as the original.
“A Baby Changes Everything” — Faith Hill
From her 2008 album Joy to the World. Written by Craig Wiseman and Tim Nichols.
I included this one on my list of Top 5 Faith Hill Singles because I love it that much. Her gospel roots blaze through this ballad about a young mother’s recognition that a baby changes everything for her. This baby — Jesus — also changes everything for the world.
“Belleau Wood” — Garth Brooks
From his 1997 album Sevens. Written by Garth Brooks and Joe Henry.
A haunting song that gives me chills, Garth’s Belleau Wood isn’t included on any of his Christmas albums, yet it tells the story of the World War I Christmas truce of 1914. While the title references the Battle of Belleau Wood in France, the truce itself occurred when German and British soldiers exchanged greetings in no man’s land, sparking a widespread unofficial ceasefire. Like “If Tomorrow Never Comes” and “Unanswered Prayers,” Garth here reveals his gift for crafting songs of emotional gravity.
(“It Must Have Been Ol’) Santa Claus” — Gary Allan
From his 2021 EP Please Come Home for Christmas. Written by Harry Connick Jr.
Christmas music is generally divided into two categories: sacred and secular. Within the secular division, you could also include a subgroup: sappy. There are plenty of sappy Christmas songs, and I like most of them, including Allan’s cover of the Eagles’ “Please Come Home for Christmas.” But I like his country-fied version of the New Orleans-flavored (“It Must Have Been Ol’) Santa Claus” even more.
“Christmas Cookies” — George Strait
From the compilation album A Country Christmas 1999. Written by Aaron Barker.
Strait delivers this one flawlessly, talk-singing his way through the simple chorus and verses that hide a sweet love story in lyrics about cookies that look like Santa Claus/ Christmas trees, and bells, and stars. No one sings this one better than King George.
“There’s a New Kid in Town” — Kathy Mattea
From her 1993 album Good News. Written by Don Cook, Curly Putman, and Keith Whitley.
Although the wise men are routinely featured in retellings of Christ’s birth — from nativity scenes sold by retailers to children’s Christmas pageants — they aren’t largely included in music. But the magi narrate this story, which reminds us that the same Jesus that was mistaken “as just another baby” at his birth is still questioned as King and Messiah. I heard Kathy’s version before the Keith Whitley original, and it still stands out as one of the best.
“The Nativity” — Lee Ann Womack
From the 2001 compilation album Christmas Cookies. Written by Lee Ann Womack
I think I’m right in saying Lee Ann wrote this one, but information online was spotty. Regardless, the song’s narrator reminisces about her mother’s nativity at Christmastime and the Easter service “at the Central Baptist Church.” In those memories, adult Lee Ann asks profound questions of herself and all modern-day Christians: Could I pursue the unknowing to accept Him in their home/ If I were there with Jesus would I help to right the wrong.
“O Holy Night” — Martina McBride
From her 1998 album White Christmas. Written by Adolphe Adam and John Sullivan Dwight.
Few singers have the chops to meet the demands of this traditional carol, but Martina McBride’s control brings out both the reverence and grandeur of Christ’s birth.
“Even Santa Claus Gets the Blues” — Marty Stuart
From the 2003 compilation album A Very Special Acoustic Christmas. Written by Marty Stuart.
Born in Philadelphia, Mississippi, and largely raised on the road touring with bluegrass legend Lester Flatt before joining Johnny Cash’s road band, Marty Stuart is a master of seamlessly blending country, rockabilly, and rhythm and blues. His recognition that even Santa gets the blues isn’t whiney but a reminder that sometimes we all get down, but we keep moving forward.
“Merry Christmas from the Family” — Montgomery Gentry
Released in 2000. Written by Robert Earl Keen.
The country duo released their cover of Robert Earl Keen’s holiday ode to family dysfunction on the B-side of their single “All Night Long.” There probably aren’t a lot of country acts who could pull it off as well as Eddie and T-roy. Whether you call them rednecks or outlaws, you can picture them buying bean dip and Diet Rite at the Quickpak on Christmas.
“Christmas Time’s a Comin’” — Patty Loveless
From her 2002 album Bluegrass & White Snow: A Mountain Christmas. Written by Tex Logan.
Back when TNN churned out country music entertainment from Music City, Riders in the Sky hosted a Christmas special with guest star Reba McEntire. (I taped it and wore out that old VHS.) Their comedy-musical jam included “Christmas Time’s a Comin.’” Patty’s cover leans into bluegrass instrumentation, the perfect vehicle for her pure but raw delivery.
“Meet Me Under the Mistletoe” — Randy Travis
From his 1989 album An Old Time Christmas. Written by Joe Collins, Mark Irwin, and Betsy Jackson.
It was a toss-up between this one and “How Do I Wrap My Heart Up for Christmas” for Randy’s entry on the list. This one is more upbeat and a nice reminder for all you couples out there to make some time for each other during the busy holiday season.
“A Christmas Letter” — Reba McEntire
From her 1987 album Merry Christmas to You. Written by John Greenebaum, Paul Nelson, and Gene Nelson.
As a kid, I could memorize lyrics quickly, but I rarely paid attention to the meaning of the songs I consumed. So even though I listened to Reba’s first Christmas album religiously, it was a while before I fully grasped that Santa Claus was the old man sitting alone at the antique desk, penning his own Christmas letter for peace on earth. Reba is at her My Kind of Country best on this album, and her voice and style fit the rustic imagery of this song. For extra credit, check out her version of “The Christmas Guest,” also on this album.
“It Wasn’t His Child” — Sawyer Brown
From their Wide Open album. Written by Skip Ewing.
Like Garth’s Belleau Wood, this song was included on a non-Christmas album. Understandably, Joseph doesn’t get the same recognition as Mary, so a song from his perspective is compelling. Skip Ewing deserves a lot of credit for penning such thoughtful lyrics, and Sawyer Brown’s delivery is heartfelt.
“Beautiful Star of Bethlehem” — The Judds
From their 1987 album Christmas Time with the Judds. Written by A.L. Philips.
Wynonna provides a strong vocal foundation while Naomi adds unblemished harmonies to give this Christmas favorite a traditional country feel.
“Santa Looked a Lot Like Daddy” — Travis Tritt
From his 1992 album A Travis Tritt Christmas: Loving Time of the Year. Written by Buck Owens and Don Rich.
I’m not saying Travis does it better than Buck Owens because who can imitate Buck’s unique phrasing? But Travis certainly honors Buck with his worthy cover of Bakersville’s best. Brad Paisley’s version is also worth your time.
“Take A Walk Through Bethlehem” — Trisha Yearwood
From her 1994 album The Sweetest Gift. Written by Ashley Cleveland, John Barlow Jarvis, and Wally Wilson.
When Trisha adds gospel flair to her traditional country voice, the results are darn-near perfect. Such is the case on this soul-stirring walk through Bethlehem.
“Do You Hear What I Hear” — Vince Gill
From his 1993 album Let There Be Peace on Earth. Written by Noel Regney and Gloria Shayne Baker.
I don’t know if Vince introduced me to this song or if I simply learned the lyrics from his version, but it stands out in my memory. His pure tenor makes every Christmas song special, and this one is no exception.
I know I missed some great songs — my mom may even withhold my Christmas present for leaving out her favorite, ‘Mary, Did You Know?’ But I’m confident these 25 will put you on the road to discovering even more country Christmas classics — from ‘90s artists and beyond — which is what Roots & Rhinestones is all about.
I hope your heart is light this holiday season, but like Marty sings, “Even Santa Claus Gets the Blues.” Whether you’re grieving, far from family, facing illness, or overwhelmed by life’s challenges, you aren’t alone. Find education and resources on mental health at https://www.nami.org/support-education/.
And if listening to Christmas music isn’t your jam, I’ll be back soon with the first of a series on the Class of ‘89, starting with a man I believe is destined for the Country Music Hall of Fame. Do you know who I have in mind?

Leave a Reply